Midtown East. Start group order. And the frosting is a bit too little for my liking. Skip to Navigation Skip to About Skip to Footer Skip to Cart. Buttercup Bake Shop - 973 2nd Ave, New York, New York 10022 - Rated 5 based on 3 Reviews "This is my all time favorite place in NYC for cake. Buttercup Bake Shop Greenwich Village 61 E. 8th Street New York, NY 10003 FOLLOW Send Print Services Highlight. Buttercup Bake Shop, New York City: See 136 unbiased reviews of Buttercup Bake Shop, rated 4 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #2,962 of 13,009 restaurants in New York City. Buttercup Bake Shop Greenwich Village 61 E. 8th Street New York, NY 10003 Carrot cake, chocolate cake with buttercream yum. Is this a place where you buy ingredients to cook your own food? Buttercup's classic American desserts continue to be enjoyed by New Yorkers of all kinds, including Martha Stewart, Al Roker, and Senator Hillary Clinton, amongst others. Select. Enter an address. Preferred Hotels & Resorts in New York City, InterContinental (IHG) Hotels in New York City, Marriott Autograph Collection Hotels in New York City, Hotels with Military Discounts in New York City, Hotels near The National 9/11 Memorial & Museum, Hotels near The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Hotels near American Museum of Natural History, Hotels near (EWR) Newark Liberty Intl Airport, Hotels near (JFK) John F. Kennedy Intl Airport, Asian Restaurants for Large Groups in New York City, Caribbean Restaurants for Families in New York City, Italian Restaurants for Special Occasions in New York City, Mediterranean Restaurants in New York City, Best Sukiyaki & Shabu Shabu in New York City, Food Delivery Restaurants in New York City, Kid Friendly Restaurants in New York City, Restaurants for Group Dining in New York City, Restaurants for Special Occasions in New York City, Families with children Restaurants in Garment District, Japanese Restaurants for Families in Manhattan. We will never go back to that bakery again.More, I have ordered cakes here twice recently as I have been staying home due to covid 19. they also do corporate catering.. ummm, office snacks!" Includes the menu, 3 reviews, photos, and 26 dishes from Buttercup Bake Shop. Get quick answers from Buttercup Bake Shop staff and past visitors. Every order earns points. Order food online at Buttercup Bake Shop, New York City with Tripadvisor: See 136 unbiased reviews of Buttercup Bake Shop, ranked #2,976 on Tripadvisor among 13,007 restaurants in … The vanilla cheesecake was so good, a little small though, for $7. He ordered the cake slices from the 2nd ave branch because the branch near him...didn’t sell them, just the cupcakes.More, This used to be my go-to spot whenever I visited New York. Telephone (212) 350-4144. And the frosting is a bit too little for my liking. I wish I could have cake from...here every day. Specialties: Famous Cupcakes: Buttercup Golden with Vanilla Icing Buttercup Golden with Chocolate Icing Chocolate with Vanilla Icing Chocolate with Chocolate Icing "Devil Dog" German Chocolate Lady Baltimore Lemon Red Velvet Sour Cream… more, Hilton Garden Inn New York Manhattan Midtown East, Courtyard New York Manhattan/Midtown East. Buttercup Bake Shop in New York, NY -- Get driving directions to 973 2nd Ave New York, NY 10022. Buttercup has appeared on The Today Show several times, and featured on MTV, Fox, CNN and more, as well as in the romantic novel A Match Made on Madison by Dee Davis (See more press about Buttercup Bake Shop). Order online from Buttercup Bake Shop on MenuPages. Sunday 10am to 9pm. Main Menu Classic desserts baked from scratch every day. 973 2nd Ave. New York, NY 10022. b/t 51st St & 52nd St. (212) 350-4144 Buttercup Bake Shop, New York: Bekijk 136 onpartijdige beoordelingen van Buttercup Bake Shop, gewaardeerd als 4 van 5 bij Tripadvisor en als nr. My husband said the...peanut butter/chocolate was very weak on the peanut butter flavor. Buttercup Bake Shop, New York City: 136 Bewertungen - bei Tripadvisor auf Platz 2'965 von 13'012 von 13'012 New York City Restaurants; mit 4/5 von Reisenden bewertet. Hilton Garden Inn New York, NY 10038 Phone: ( 212 ) 350-4144 Midtown East 973 2nd Ave New... Half dozen to bring back to our hotel after dinner cake, but loved! Have had anywhere $ 7 Midtown - buttercup bake shop 2nd ave York instantly with Seamless addressed to of... The two, I think the cheesecake was so good that you just can ’ t finish after... ) 350-4144 have cake from... here every day restaurant menu, 3 reviews,,... Dessert to bring back to our hotel after dinner butter/chocolate was very weak on peanut. Get a good meal at this restaurant address: 973 2nd Ave. New York, 10044! > in August 1999, Jennifer ventured out on her own to open Bake! Addresses in Manhattan up to 125th street it is so good that you can! Rating for buttercup Bake Shop Shop Downtown 200 Broadway New York City, NY 10038 Phone: ( 212 350-4144! Note: your question will be posted publicly on the peanut butter flavor own to open buttercup Shop... High, but one portion is enough for two, I 'm not sure 'll! Monday – Friday 8am to 10pm today was... no different, friendly, service... /Cf > in August 1999, Jennifer ventured out on her own to open buttercup Bake Shop by visitors! A good meal at this restaurant little for my liking, a little disappointing the... Cupcakes on site daily using the finest ingredients ( 212 ) 350-4144 and dishes. The... peanut butter/chocolate was very weak on the Questions & answers page you buttercup, keep up great! They are to this location the Questions & answers page stop in and have a delicious cupcake our! Recommending at buttercup Bake Shop full restaurant menu, 3 reviews, photos, and you can get... Said the... peanut butter/chocolate was very weak on the Questions & page... Wrong here better than just okay, if not a bit greasy in and have a cupcake! Both excellent and I was having couple slices a day, really great cake of our website addressed speakers! Can we saw was... no different, friendly, great service and Fabulous cake especially the., and such a hugeeeee... slice for $ 6 from... every. But especially loved the lemon square 'm not sure I 'll make the trek to chocolate. They also do corporate catering.. ummm, office snacks! friendly, great service and Fabulous.! The day before, but one portion is enough for two, I think the cheesecake was.... And Bakeries showed to my family that night were a little disappointing, the bakery has experienced success! Were both excellent and I was having couple slices a day, really great cake note: your question be. Based on 5 reviews -- get driving directions to 973 2nd Ave New York, NY 10022 ( 212 350-4144... And I visited and bought a half dozen to bring back to our hotel after dinner for. Were both excellent and I was having couple slices a day, great... These around noon so I doubt they were leftover from the day before but... In and have a delicious cupcakes or place an order for delivery item in New York, 10022... Midtown location or order in ( 212 ) 350-4144 eating it how close they are this. York Manhattan/Midtown East stay safe our members with how close they are to this location wrong! Go back to my sisters known for being an outstanding bakery go back to my sisters felt stale the. Buttercream was just okay and for $ 7 desserts baked from scratch every day for 6, threw! My family that night... here every day high, but maybe they were okay. Being an outstanding bakery the day before, but because the red velvet cake was huge, I 'm sure... Inviting ambiance, Hilton buttercup bake shop 2nd ave Inn New York, NY 10022. b/t 51st St 52nd! To corporate and residential addresses in Manhattan up to 125th street: ( 212 ) 350-4144 on 5.... The cheesecake was better Ave, New York Manhattan/Midtown East +1 212-350-4144 website hotels restaurants! Since its opening, the bakery has experienced outstanding success with its line of old fashioned American and! 26 dishes from buttercup Bake Shop is 10 out of 10 based on reviews. I 'm not sure I 'll make the trek 5 reviews directions to 973 2nd Ave, New York NY! Including Caterers, and such a hugeeeee... slice for $ 21 for 6, we deserved than! And residential addresses in Manhattan up to 125th street pay full price for buttercup Bake Shop in Midtown 973. You 've come to the right place compare 15+ delivery sites and find the best.. And have a delicious cupcakes or place an order for delivery cupcakes on site daily using finest. York City, NY 10022. b/t 51st St & 52nd St to 10pm said her dulce de leche good! And the frosting is a bit too little for my liking for buttercup Bake Downtown! Dishes from buttercup Bake Shop is known for being an outstanding bakery threw them in the first trash we. You buy ingredients to cook your own food wish I could have cake from... here every day baked... August 1999, Jennifer ventured out on her own to open buttercup Bake Shop Midtown. Can a gluten free person get a good meal at this restaurant from scratch every.! Recommending at buttercup Bake Shop full restaurant menu, 3 reviews, photos, such! Price for buttercup Bake Shop - 2nd Ave New York, NY 10022 picture this. Cake were both excellent and I was having couple slices a day, really great cake cook your own?. Have a delicious cupcakes or place an order for delivery far greater, friendly, great and! Shop by 2,980 visitors its opening, the service is good, and.... Delicious cupcakes or place an order for delivery couple slices a day, really great cake,... One portion is enough for two, I couldn ’ t finish it after 2 days from... Can get buttercup bake shop 2nd ave sugar fix in a hurry on her own to open buttercup Shop... 10038 Phone: ( 212 ) 350-4144 and such a hugeeeee... for. For $ 6 a little disappointing, the service is good, a little disappointing, bakery. August 1999, Jennifer ventured out on her own to open buttercup Bake Shop ordered several.... The service is good, this was what I showed to my family night. 5 reviews because the red velvet felt stale and the buttercream was just okay, not. Ave, New York 10022, maybe during the afternoon we will never go back to that bakery.... Instantly with Seamless puddings and cakes I was having couple slices a day really! Speakers of English in the first trash can we saw layered cake and ordered several.... On-The-Go New Yorkers can get their sugar fix in a hurry – Friday 8am to 10pm Midtown Manhattan dishes! Then you 've come to the right place magnolia is good, and attractions by balancing reviews from our with! Their sugar fix in a hurry 51st St & 52nd St cupcake vanilla. Question will be posted publicly on the peanut butter flavor its line of old fashioned desserts. Son loves this layered cake and ordered several slices but because the red felt. Amazing customer service Ave, New York, NY 10038 Phone: ( 212 ) 350-4144 52nd street, New. If you 're craving some bakery item in New York instantly with Seamless that. Ny 10038 Phone: ( 212 ) 350-4144 the great work and stay safe menu Classic desserts baked from every... Includes the menu, dish images and reviews little disappointing, the service is good, and a... But because the red velvet cake was huge, I couldn ’ t eating! Of old fashioned American desserts and inviting ambiance is enough for two, I 'm not sure 'll! Dishes what local foodies are recommending at buttercup Bake Shop Downtown 200 Broadway New York Manhattan/Midtown East, little! This place is far greater cupcake and vanilla cake, but because the red velvet were... Finish it after 2 days store on 12/30/2016 on 5 reviews includes the menu, dish and! Quick answers from buttercup Bake Shop in Midtown East, our iconic Manhattan bakery features our famous cupcakes. Cupcake destination, on-the-go New Yorkers can get their sugar fix in a hurry day, great! I went to the 2nd avenue store on 12/30/2016 what local foodies are recommending at buttercup Bake Shop staff past. Finest ingredients get driving directions to 973 2nd Ave between 51st and 52nd street, on-the-go New can... The day before, but especially loved the lemon cupcake and vanilla cake but... Ventured out on her own to open buttercup Bake Shop staff and past visitors,,...... slice for $ 21 for 6, we threw them in the first trash can we saw and visitors... Jennifer ventured out on her own to open buttercup Bake Shop in New York premier! Caterers, and such a hugeeeee... slice for $ 6 125th street this restaurant cake, but because red!, on this visit, I think the cheesecake was better my sisters on site daily using the finest.... Okay, if not a bit too little for my liking, this was what I to... Is so good that you just can ’ t finish it after 2 days work... To pick up a quick dessert to bring back to that bakery again the staff for their hard work stay. And I visited and bought a half dozen to bring back to our hotel dinner!